MHG4898 - Cave or rock shelter - Creag A'Chapuill
A cave or rock shelter at Creag A'Chapuill, Rubh an Dunain, Skye.
Type and Period (1)
- CAVE (Early Bronze Age to Late Iron Age - 2400 BC to 560 AD)
A cave or rock shelter at Creag A'Chapuill, Rubh an Dunain, Skye.
NG31NE 5 3995 1625.
(NG 3995 1625) A small and shallow cave (15' greatest width, 9' greatest depth) excavated September, 1932 by W Lindsay Scott. The floor of the cave proved to be very disturbed and the stratification therefore mainly unreliable. However, from the few finds, its occupation seems to have commenced at the time of the later stage of the development of the chambered cairn nearby (NG31NE 2) when beakers had ousted Windmill Hill ware, and ended by the time the galleried dun (NG31NE 1) was built.
The finds included beaker sherds of A c type, with refuse representative of a stone-knapper's workshop in the same level and immediately above; also Iron Age sherds, some iron slag and a primitive Catalan forge. Neither domestic hearth nor R.B. pottery was found but a few fragments of pottery may indicate casual use in the early centuries of the present era.
The stone knapping aspect of this site is listed under the heading of 'Mesolithic Survivals', and given a possible association with the industry of Rudh'an Achaidh Mh'oir in South Morar (A D Lacaille 1954).
W L Scott 1934; A D Lacaille 1954.
Cave as described.
Visited by OS (C F W) 8 April 1961.
In 1932 Scott excavated a shallow cave or rock-shelter set into the W end of Creag a' Chapuill ridge. The cave is the farthest E of the prehistoric monuments on the Rubh' an Dunain peninsula, and has entered the archaeological literature under this name. It has also been known as Rudh' an Dunain, and is situated at an altitude of about 31m OD, 200m inland from the N end of Soay Sound and about 5 km SSW of the nearest public road at Culnamean, Minginish. The cave was found to measure about 9' (2.7m) in depth by 15' (4.6m) transversely and was exposed to the prevailing wind and rain. The remains were interpreted as evidence for Beaker period stone-knapping, Iron Age iron-smelting and transitory occupation in the Early Historic period and in modern times. Among the finds there was a wooden blade-like object which was found on its edge about 6" (150mm) from the Iron Age furnace and apparently in the same layer. One corner and part of the surface were reported to have suffered from rot, but the remains measured 1'6" (0.46m) in length by 5?" (140mm) in breadth and ?" (19mm) in thickness. In the ambiguous and distorted stratigraphy of the cave, it is uncertain whether this object was connected with iron-smelting activities, as Scott suggests. The published photograph suggests an identification as an oar-blade similar to that from Lochlea (NS43SE 5) but its date is uncertain. The artifact is in store at the Royal Museum of Scotland under accession number NMS HM 301 and is identified in the accessions register as a 'spatulate wooden object'. It measures 0.45m in length by up to 140mm transversely across the blade; the blade and the diagonally-cut shoulders account for 70% of the former figure. The thickness is about 15mm throughout and there is no differentiation between the dorsal and ventral surfaces. The timber is brown in colour with burnt patches of charcoal-like texture flaking away in places, and is heavily-grained in the plane of the longitudinal axis; slight splitting has occurred. The sides, which were possibly chamfered, and the end of the blade have been worn down and rounded, giving the impression of considerable antiquity. The butt end was probably cut square across but has become irregularly worn. It is now assymetrical in form, possibly as a result of wear; on the assumption that it was formerly symmetrical, it would have measured about 160mm across. In the absence of any evident parallel, the function of the object remains uncertain. The breadth of the blade and the shortness of the handle would, however, seem to militate against its use for maritime propulsion.
W L Scott 1934; S E Rees 1979; RMS accessions register: typescript continuation catalogue; R J C Mowat 1996, visited January 1988.
This is a rock shelter which shows signs of reletively recent use by campers including fires. Lindsey Scott's excavation trench running into the cave is visible and although the interior has apparently been cleaned out, there seems to be a substantial undisturbed area of deposits surviving outside the entrance (although it is difficult to see which is undisturbed and which is spoilheap). JW visited in the company of M. Wildgoose, S.Birch and M.Carmichael on 30/5/02. Two small fragments of worked bloodstone and some small pieces of iron slag were picked up from the surface and left with Mary Carmichael (Highland Council Skye and Lochalsh Heritage Officer).
The cave was assessed against Historic Environment Scotland's Scheduling criteria in 2017 and it was considered that it shoud be Scheduled. <1>
The cave was Scheduled by Historic Environment Scotland in 2017. <2>
Pottery sherds including two beaker sherds and a possible food vessel sherd, a core, flakes and scrapers of flint, bloodstone, jasper, chert and chalcedony, and wooden spatulate object are listed in the NMS catalogue. Acc. Nos. HM 278- HM 301. <3>
- --- Text/Publication/Monograph: Rees, S E. 1979. Agricultural implements in prehistoric and Roman Britain. Brit Ser. 69. vol. 1, 320-1.
- --- Text/Publication/Monograph: Gibson, A M. 1982. Beaker domestic sites: a study of the domestic pottery of the late third and early socond millennia B C in the British Isles. Brit Ser. 107. Vol. 1, 233.
- --- Text/Publication/Volume: Clarke, D L. 1970. Beaker pottery of Great Britain and Ireland. Vol. 2, No. 1676 F.
- --- Text/Publication/Volume: Lacaille, A D. 1954. The Stone Age in Scotland. 299.
- --- Text/Publication/Volume: Mowat, R J C. 1996. The logboats of Scotland, with notes on related artefact types. viii, 95, 105, 113, 138, no. A65; fig. 42, tabs. 1 and 9.
- --- Text/Publication/Article: Scott, W L. 1934. 'Excavation of Rudh' an Dunain cave, Skye', Proc Soc Antiq Scot Vol. 68 1933-4, p.200-23. Proc Soc Antiq Scot. 200-23. 200-23; lan, illust..
- <1> Text/Designation Notification/Scheduled Monument: Historic Environment Scotland. 2017. Assessment against Scheduling criteria: Creag a' Chapaill Cave, Rubha an Dunain, Isle of Skye. Historic Environment Scotland.
- <2> Text/Designation Notification/Scheduled Monument: Historic Environment Scotland. 2017. Addition to the Schedule of Monuments: SM13676: Loch na h-Airde canal, harbour and noosts, Rubha an Dunain, Isle of Skye. Historic Environment Scotland. 16/10/2017. Digital.
- <3> Dataset/Database File: National Museums Scotland. 2019. Highland Finds from the NMS Catalogue. National Museums Scotland. Digital. HM 278- HM 301.
|Grid reference||Centred NG 3995 1625 (30m by 30m) (Buffered by site type)|
|Geographical Area||SKYE AND LOCHALSH|
- BEAKER (Bronze Age - 2400 BC to 551 BC)
- SHERD (Iron Age - 550 BC? to 560 AD?)
- SLAG (Iron Age - 550 BC to 560 AD)
- PADDLE (Iron Age - 550 BC? to 560 AD?)
- VESSEL (Bronze Age - 2400 BC? to 551 BC?)
- FLAKE (Undated)
- SCRAPER (TOOL) (Undated)
- CORE (Undated)
Related Monuments/Buildings (0)
Related Investigations/Events (0)
External Links (2)
- http://portal.historicenvironment.scot/designation/SM13675 (Link to online HES designation record)
- https://canmore.org.uk/site/11025 (View HES Canmore entry for this site)
Comments and Feedback
Do you have any more information about this record? Please feel free to comment with information and photographs, or ask any questions, using the "Disqus" tool below. Comments are moderated, and we aim to respond/publish as soon as possible.